• I Cast Fist
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    4 months ago

    To be all powerful does God need to be able to create paradoxes?

    To be all powerful means you literally create all the rules, including any that might lead to paradoxes, or being able to create a set of rules that lead to no paradoxes, ever.

    The all loving part I think gets resolved by the free will idea, too — he’s not going to step in and be a nanny.

    Again, he creates the rules, the “state machine”. If we humans can reach a “failed” (evil) state, it’s only because it’s an option that has been created.

    Also, free will automatically breaks either god’s omniscience (and omnipotence) or being all-loving. If god knows everything that will ever happen, free will cannot exist except as an illusion, for everything is already predetermined. If free will exists, well, then we can safely imply that god is not all powerful, for god cannot predict our decisions.