Days after board members laughed at the exchange, the Washington County Board of Education called the comments “shocking,” saying “no explanation can justify that.”
Perhaps the argument that it isn’t possible to assess merit for a job position is so far outside the realms of reason that asking for clarification is the only way to formulate an answer.
But if you want a simple, quotable answer for the obvious question as it is written, here you go:
Asses the criteria for which a job would be considered to be successfully performed.
Check if historical evidence/experience/current skill/expected future growth gives indication that the candidate could meet or exceed those criteria.
Rank the candidates, based on how well they match to the success criteria.
???
Profit?
It’s tremendously disappointing to see people act like assessing fitness for a role isn’t a thing that has been going on since the dawn of civilisation.
Get a grip.
Now, if you want argue that this isn’t how things are currently done ? I’m right there with you.
The system is a shambolic remnant of what it should be ? couldn’t agree more.
A lot of it is probably by design ? sure, i’m down for that perspective.
But “It isn’t possible to assess merit for a job role”, is a troll at best or extreme ignorance at worst.
If people weren’t asking “are you sure that this is what you meant?” i’d be worried for the state of basic reasoning.
Perhaps the argument that it isn’t possible to assess merit for a job position is so far outside the realms of reason that asking for clarification is the only way to formulate an answer.
But if you want a simple, quotable answer for the obvious question as it is written, here you go:
It’s tremendously disappointing to see people act like assessing fitness for a role isn’t a thing that has been going on since the dawn of civilisation.
Get a grip.
Now, if you want argue that this isn’t how things are currently done ? I’m right there with you.
The system is a shambolic remnant of what it should be ? couldn’t agree more.
A lot of it is probably by design ? sure, i’m down for that perspective.
But “It isn’t possible to assess merit for a job role”, is a troll at best or extreme ignorance at worst.
If people weren’t asking “are you sure that this is what you meant?” i’d be worried for the state of basic reasoning.