Hey so I’m gonna be streaming Over on twitch at 1200 EST / 1700 GMT if anyone wants to see me get a little too giddy with some Durge evilness…

  • derpgonEnglish
    5·
    10 months ago

    Was always strange that you can wish for anything besides someone’s death. Can you with for their heart to stop? Explode? Turn to lava? It is considered death? Or is death in Wish-sense considered “true death” - with no way to revivify/true revivify?

    • Mnemnosyne@sh.itjust.worksEnglish
      2·
      10 months ago

      It’s not really anything other than someone’s death. It’s more ‘these wishes are safe and will work out how you want’. Anything beyond those, the DM is encouraged to respond appropriately. In 5th edition, there is actually very little that is listed as safe to wish for. In 3.5 the list was short but highly useful. In 2nd though, there were NO explicitly safe wishes. Anything could backfire.

      If you wish for a reasonable outcome that’s not on the safe list, you should get it without too much trouble, but if you wish something that’s grossly unfair, then you get what’s coming to you when it backfires.