• jaybone@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    6 months ago

    The second example is quite good imo. You would never say “I’m going to a bathroom.” Even if you were in a stadium with hundreds of bathrooms, you would still say you are going to the bathroom.

    Same as you might say I’m taking the train. Not usually taking a train, though I’ve heard that too sometimes. Though oddly you usually say I’m taking a plane, not the plane. Also I’m taking the freeway, not a freeway. I’m usually going to the doctor, less often than a doctor.

    • ALERT@sh.itjust.works
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      arrow-down
      5
      ·
      edit-2
      6 months ago

      The second example is quite good imo. You would never say “I’m going to a bathroom.” Even if you were in a stadium with hundreds of bathrooms, you would still say you are going to the bathroom.

      you are justifying this statement “because of reasons” :) this is not a logical explanation. there are a bunch of bathrooms in the world. Am I going to the one specific that was mentioned before in the context? then it’s “to the bathroom”. is this bathroom just a random one that I will encounter on my way? then why not “to a bathroom”?

      same with trains: even if you are speaking about a train route with a specific number, you are not talking about a specific train, then it should be “I’ll be taking a train”. if you are going to take the specific locomotive for a ride in a museum, then, obviously, you are going to take “the train”. this sounds logical for the usage of Articles in the English language, at least in my head.

      same with doctors: if you are going to a specific doctor, and your opponent knows which one by the context, then it should be “to the doctor”, otherwise it would be a random doctor that will be assigned to you as soon as you arrive to the clinic, it cannot be “the doctor” by the same principle I always thought exists :)

      I’m not even talking about the option of using a subject without an article, like in Ukrainian. “I’m going to bathroom”. if I wanted to say which one, I would have stated it, but as soon as I am going to pee in a random bathroom I find, why can’t it be just “I’m going to bathroom”? :D yeah, now it sounds like a verb :D

      whoa, another meaningless “the” appeared. “The English Language” phrasing is used despite there are at least four? five? English languages.

      so… it’s complicated :D but this does not prevent English from being The Language of the World, and I cannot name a language that could have been on its place.

      • SurpriZe@lemm.ee
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        6 months ago

        This is gold! But what I also find confusing is the ultimate difference between Present Perfect and Past Simple…

      • Hexarei
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        6 months ago

        My autistic ass has always thought of it as “I’m going to the (specific) bathroom (that I will be using)”