Ars Technica brings us today’s shocking privacy news: ‘Apple holds the master decryption key when it comes to iCloud security, privacy’. Oh my. The story is definitely worth a rea…
This is not new to me. While this is about iCloud and not the iPhone device itself, wasn’t there news in the past where Apple didn’t want cooperate and give the FBI the master key to unlock iPhone device? According to Apple, they have a master key and won’t give it to anyone, other than unlocking devices for repair.
If that ever happens, we don’t know. Apple is an US company, so who knows. My point is, this is not new news (to me), because that is known and Apples strategy.
That’s not true. Apple does not have a master key for iPhones. IIRC the FBI wanted Apple to help by providing custom firmware that allowed them to do unlimited attempts on the passcode.
This is a letter from Tim Cook himself in 2016, regarding this topic. I might be wrong, but remember those articles talking about this subject and the master key for the iPhone. I’ve not read this document yet (just found it when researching to refresh memories).
The government suggests this tool could only be used once, on one phone. But that’s simply not true. Once created, the technique could be used over and over again, on any number of devices. In the physical world, it would be the equivalent of a master key, capable of opening hundreds of millions of locks — from restaurants and banks to stores and homes. No reasonable person would find that acceptable.
So without having full understanding whats going on, it looks like Tim was talking about an equivalent effect of a master key, when using such a tool (the firmware?). Maybe there comes this misconception in the media?
This is not new to me. While this is about iCloud and not the iPhone device itself, wasn’t there news in the past where Apple didn’t want cooperate and give the FBI the master key to unlock iPhone device? According to Apple, they have a master key and won’t give it to anyone, other than unlocking devices for repair.
If that ever happens, we don’t know. Apple is an US company, so who knows. My point is, this is not new news (to me), because that is known and Apples strategy.
That’s not true. Apple does not have a master key for iPhones. IIRC the FBI wanted Apple to help by providing custom firmware that allowed them to do unlimited attempts on the passcode.
https://www.apple.com/customer-letter/
This is a letter from Tim Cook himself in 2016, regarding this topic. I might be wrong, but remember those articles talking about this subject and the master key for the iPhone. I’ve not read this document yet (just found it when researching to refresh memories).
So without having full understanding whats going on, it looks like Tim was talking about an equivalent effect of a master key, when using such a tool (the firmware?). Maybe there comes this misconception in the media?