• UnderpantsWeevil@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    4 hours ago

    pacifism is cowardly when inaction enables bad actors.

    But pacifism isn’t inaction. It is action with the intent to do no harm.

    not everyone values peace

    The value of peace is social, not individual. You value peace when you know you have everything you want from the status quo. You embrace violence as a means of shifting conditions in your favor.

    But violence comes at a grander social price. Simply embracing it because someone else has only compounds the costs.

    the paradox of tolerance is not a paradox

    The question of a socially acceptable degree of tolerance is a difficult one to answer philosophically and even more difficult to implement as social policy.

    It is not strictly a paradox, but it is an unsolved problem.

    don’t let the illusion of a peaceful society lull you into a vulnerable trance

    The cost of violent action is what dissuades a violent response. People aren’t in a trance, they are taking a calculated risk.

    never play fair with your enemy

    Violating a social compact erodes trust. You reap a short term gain while everyone pays a long term price.

    “Playing fair” is about establishing a social compact that everyone recognizes as beneficial. Violating broadly beneficial norms means accruing more enemies with whom you feel compelled to play unfairly.

    the utopia that most considered a pipe dream became a feasible reality

    The utopian era ended with WW1 and the industrialization of modern warfare. The 21st century has seen wave after wave of new investments in warfare, while domestic improvements and social welfare advances have ground nearly to a halt.

    If there is a utopian future, it can only come with the abolition of international militarism. Otherwise, we continue to descend into generation after generation of escalating conflict and unchecked immolation of life and property.

    • cowardsgfy@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      arrow-down
      6
      ·
      edit-2
      4 hours ago

      But pacifism isn’t inaction. It is action with the intent to do no harm.

      sure thing, pussy

      violence comes at a grander social price. Simply embracing it because someone else has only compounds the costs.

      hitler needed more americans like you

      It is not strictly a paradox, but it is an unsolved problem.

      nah

      The cost of violent action

      the cost of non violent action is to let sociopaths win.

      Violating a social compact erodes trust. You reap a short term gain while everyone pays a long term price.

      we’re fighting for the future of humanity and all the life on this planet. that battle will be decided this century. you’re the one that’s short sighted.

      The utopian era ended with WW1

      STFU with your poindexter BS. you know what the fuck i mean when i say utopia. “uh akshually” just STFU

      just STFU. you’re almost as dense as flying squid

      • UnderpantsWeevil@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        4 hours ago

        The utopian era ended with WW1 STFU with your poindexter BS. you know what the fuck i mean when i say utopia.

        Buddy, you don’t know what you mean. These words have a historical context. They don’t just mean what you having bouncing around between your ears. Utopianism describes a series of real social movements that involved actual people organizing to build intentional communities. Its not just vibes.

        • cowardsgfy@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          4 hours ago

          sure thing, poindexter.

          let’s go ask 100 people in the street what they think utopia means.