I’ve been waiting to finish up with some major life stuff before diving into the world of 3D printers. Now that is finally behind me, and I am currently trying to find out which printer I want so that I can place an order.

So far I’ve set my eyes on the new Prusa CORE One. It ticks a lot of the boxes that I think I am after, including:

  • As open as I can get (before going into that Voron-stuff, which I think I’m not ready for). I don’t want to be bogged down with having to run proprietary slicers through Wine and things like that. I am not sure how big of an issue that is with e.g. Bambu or Creality (if at all), but I’ve seen enough rug-pulls and enshittification processes that I don’t really want to risk that. I want to be sure that I can use FOSS tools such as Blender and FreeCAD for design, and similarly open slicers, and the whole workflow will work just fine.
  • As future-proof as I can possibly hope for. I think the upgrade path from the MK4 to CORE One shows that they are serious about sustainability and longevity of their devices, and as far as I can tell, I should have no troubles sourcing replacement parts. I also want to support companies with this philosophy.
  • Has a decent print volume (I know there are bigger, maybe I will be constrained by this at some point?)
  • Enclosed - a major reason I did not want the MK4S was that it was not enclosed (but maybe you can get an enclosure?). It will be placed in my study where I spend most of my computer time (which often times is a lot, so I imagine I will be in the room while it is printing). I imagine, with the additional filter, that it will be better with an enclosure. Also, it will be easier to keep good temperature control during prints, as it can get cold here during winter.
  • Locally produced (I’m EU based).

I understand that other manufacturers provide more “bang for the buck” and that I in that sense will be overpaying feature-wise. I am fine with that given my emphasis on the above criteria.

However, I am a complete newbie to 3D-printing. I am sure there are some limitations I have not thought about, and I was wondering if there are any major things I have not thought about that would actually affect me negatively and should make me reconsider this model?

  • TheYang@lemmy.worldEnglish
    5·
    2 days ago

    I think you have it down pretty well.

    It’s not perfectly open Source. Upgradeability can be reasonably expected, it’s not the cheapest, but a very good option.

    One more thing that could be considered is if one believes Prusa may die as a company. That would of course reduce the aspect of upgradeability. Personally I believe they are fine, and just growing slower (more organically? Than Bambu for example).

    Also Bambu will bring out another printer in a similar timeframe as Core 1 will come out. Depending on priorities it can make sense to wait to compare the offerings.

    But I don’t think, given your reasonig you’d be making a mistake if you could buy now.

    • bluewing@lemm.eeEnglish
      3·
      2 days ago

      I’m not so sure Prusa will go out of business. But I can see them switching focus from consumer machines to “pro-consumer” machines due to the race to the bottom with consumer machines. It’s impossible for Prusa to compete with Chinese manufacturers on price. The XL and the HT90 already appear to be moves towards that focus.

      While I have recently added a Bambu A1 mini to sit along side my trusty old Mk3s+, that Prusa ain’t going nowhere. You will get my Mk3s when you can pry it from my cold dead hands…

      • cyberwolfie@lemmy.mlOPEnglish
        2·
        19 hours ago

        But I can see them switching focus from consumer machines to “pro-consumer” machines due to the race to the bottom with consumer machines.

        Yes, that has been my impression during my research as well.

        • bluewing@lemm.eeEnglish
          1·
          18 hours ago

          One thing that people neglect to mention when they debate “Bambu vs Prusa” is the level of support. And support costs money. Prusa’s level of support is why I chose their brand over other far more expensive printers I was looking at the time. That support level matters to a business. And they are willing to pay for it. So Prusa is well situated to enter the commercial market as a known name.

    • cyberwolfie@lemmy.mlOPEnglish
      3·
      2 days ago

      Thanks :)

      One more thing that could be considered is if one believes Prusa may die as a company. That would of course reduce the aspect of upgradeability. Personally I believe they are fine, and just growing slower (more organically? Than Bambu for example).

      Yeah, the thought had crossed my mind. From what I’ve gathered, Prusa has been playing catch-up in terms of functionality and price competitiveness and for many, the CORE One did not fully meet their expectations. I know nothing of their financial situation, but I can only imagine the general 3D-printing market growing more and more, so hopefully they can maintain a sufficient market share to keep a sustainable business going.

      If Prusa went under, I still think I would have a better chance of maintaining a functional printer than if e.g. I had a Bambu printer and they went under (although that does perhaps not seem so likely at the moment?).

      • TheYang@lemmy.worldEnglish
        5·
        2 days ago

        so hopefully they can maintain a sufficient market share to keep a sustainable business going

        When the market grows, one can lose market share and still have a sustainable business ;).
        You don’t even need a growth in revenue for sustainable businesses either.

        If Prusa went under, I still think I would have a better chance of maintaining a functional printer than if e.g. I had a Bambu printer and they went under (although that does perhaps not seem so likely at the moment?).

        That seems reasonable. Let’s not forget that Bambu only increased their Firmware-Feature update promise from 2 years (march 2025) to 4 years (march 2027) after community outcry.

        btw (I do not know either way) did a bambu printer ever get a firmware feature like Input Shaping, Phase Stepping, Crash Detection etc. as an update? For example does their LIDAR now work on textured plates? (I think it didn’t in the beginning)

      • rugburn@lemmynsfw.comEnglish
        2·
        2 days ago

        You can get both Bambu and Orca skicer(s) from the AUR if your distro is arch-based or a flatpack of either if you’re Debian based if that’s your main concern, but from what you’re saying you’re more interested in the “open-ness” of the platform. I’ve never owned a Prusa myself, but I’ve seen them in action and was very impressed. I currently run a P1S and daily-drive Debian now and couldn’t be happier, but iI do understand the concerns people have with Banbu. Sounds like you’ve done your research, and if the Prusa ticks all (or the majority) of your boxes, is local to you and you don’t mind the price tag, I don’t think you’d be disappointed at all.