I feel like it’s too complicated to make average people understand how it works, the idea is simple on the surface, but I think you’d have an endless parade of people asking “so if I have resources on my land, then what happens exactly?”
And in practice I feel like it would be a difficult transition from where we are. There’s a lot of opportunity to sabotage it if they can muddy the waters, and I feel like lobbyists would end up carving it up in a way that puts corporate profits first… It depends on assessing value of many things, and if you compromise that portion of the process it all falls apart. They might even sneak in easier eminent domain or something
Systems like this can’t be put in place through compromise, they have to be pure or it all falls apart. Maybe someday, I just don’t know how to get from here to there without a lot of middle stages
This is somewhat tangential, but what are your thoughts on Georgism – a land value tax?
I like it in theory, but I have a couple issuesn.
I feel like it’s too complicated to make average people understand how it works, the idea is simple on the surface, but I think you’d have an endless parade of people asking “so if I have resources on my land, then what happens exactly?”
And in practice I feel like it would be a difficult transition from where we are. There’s a lot of opportunity to sabotage it if they can muddy the waters, and I feel like lobbyists would end up carving it up in a way that puts corporate profits first… It depends on assessing value of many things, and if you compromise that portion of the process it all falls apart. They might even sneak in easier eminent domain or something
Systems like this can’t be put in place through compromise, they have to be pure or it all falls apart. Maybe someday, I just don’t know how to get from here to there without a lot of middle stages
Those are good points. Thank you for taking the time to respond.