Newer CPUs will generally idle lower and be more power efficient at low loads and will stay at lower load due to higher processing power. I’d go with the i5-7600.
That said I have my NAS on a Haswell era i5 cpu and it still works well at reasonable wattage. So the T20 would still work.
I don’t know why I never thought to just try it out before. Popped in a 10GBaseT module and switched over my mac studio and sure enough, it’s running just fine at 10Gb on a cat 5e run.