Slide with text: “Rust teams at Google are as productive as ones using Go, and more than twice as productive as teams using C++.”

In small print it says the data is collected over 2022 and 2023.

  • ButtonsEnglish
    5·
    8 months ago
    if random() > 0.5:
    x = 2
else:
    x = "hello"

    Where is the definition of x? What is the type of x? If you can’t identify it, neither can the LSP.

    This kind of thing actually happens when implementing interfaces, inheritance, etc. Thus, LSPs in dynamic languages are best effort both theoretically and in practice.

    • asdfasdfasdf@lemmy.world
      21·
      8 months ago
      1. Look at entire file instead of snippet.
      2. If there is anything that could create a variable x before this area, then that’s where x originates. If not, and if it’s a language where you can create x without using a keyword like let or var, then x is created in the scope in your snippet.

      Types are not necessary at all.

      • ButtonsEnglish
        31·
        8 months ago

        then x is created in the scope in your snippet

        Saying “x is defined somewhere in the entire program” isn’t satisfactory to many users. Also, you didn’t tell me what type x has. Can I do x + 5?

        • asdfasdfasdf@lemmy.world
          21·
          8 months ago
          1. That isn’t what I said at all. Reread?
          2. Find references / go to definition / rename has absolutely nothing to do with types.
          • FizzyOrange
            1·
            8 months ago

            Find references / go to definition / rename has absolutely nothing to do with types.

            It absolutely does. Without static types an IDE/LSP can’t reliably find all the references / definition and therefore can’t refactor reliably either.

            Consider something like this:

            class Foo:
  bar: int

class Baz:
  bar: str

def a(f: Foo) -> int:
  return f.bar + 1

def b(f: Baz) -> str:
  return f.bar + "1"

            Now imagine you want to rename Foo.bar or find all references to it. Impossible without the type annotations.