xkcd #2942: Fluid Speech

https://xkcd.com/2942

explainxkcd.com for #2942

Alt text:

Thank you to linguist Gretchen McCulloch for teaching me about phonetic assimilation, and for teaching me that if you stand around in public reading texts from a linguist and murmuring example phrases to yourself, people will eventually ask if you’re okay.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    10915 days ago

    I once met a girl in a bar who spoke such absolutely perfect and grammatically correct German she did sound like an alien impersonating a human.
    Or someone who very much wants to show that she’s better than you.

    Turns out she wasn’t from Germany at all. She was an immigrant from Slovakia, who had learnt German at such a high level that it sounded weird.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      74
      edit-2
      15 days ago

      I’ve had Americans ask me the meaning of words I’ve used in a sentence. Like “what’s tranquil?” (I’m non-native.)

      I blame reading.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          715 days ago

          English speakers can really enhance their vocabulary when they know French. English does have a lot of French words that most people don’t use anymore but if you use them, your vocabulary becomes off-the-charts intellectual.

          • Pseudo-intellectual. A clear communicator uses the simplest, precise word that has the precise meaning they intend, reaching most commonly for the Germanic vocabulary unless they need the subtler shades of meaning from the Latinate. A pseudo-intellectual uses Latinate vocabulary to conceal what they’re actually saying or to intimidate people who aren’t as comfortable on the Latinate side of the fence. It’s a form of intellectual bullying that, to my mind, makes the person using it look insecure (not to mention likely dishonest).

            A good communicator’s motto should be “eschew gratuitous obfuscation (see what I mean?)”.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          215 days ago

          Anglo-language conversations plus Franco-vocabulary utilization, remains a veritable trick code

          De rien

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        1915 days ago

        I once did an English language vocabulary test that yielded that I’m amongst the top 0.01% in terms of amount of English-language vocabulary.

        English is not my mother tongue and I still and often make mistakes in the use of “in”-vs-“on” or even in certain forms of past tense.

        However I read a lot in English, in various areas of knowledge, plus it turns out lots of really obscure words in English are pretty much the same as a the word in some other language I know or even pretty much the Latin word, so when I didn’t know that was the English word for that, I can often guess the meaning.

        All this to say that I absolutelly agree with you that it’s a reading thing, plus at more specialized language level, the “knowledge of foreign languages” also has some impact.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        915 days ago

        Got called a rich kid for knowing the word “carafe.” Pretty sure I learned it from a book, my parents didn’t have carafe with mountain spring water or some shit around the house.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          315 days ago

          I learned it trying to fix a coffee maker. It’s news to me that it ain’t a coffee specific word.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            114 days ago

            The term “carafe” puts me in mind of a crystal glass container of between half a litre and two litres of volume for wine or water. What is it in relation to coffee? The glass bowl the coffee drips into in one of those dripping coffee makers?

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              English
              114 days ago

              Exactly that. I picture it as one of those big jugs on an industrial coffee machine with the black or orange plastic to indicate if it has caffeine

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          215 days ago

          I learned that word from my dad when I was a child. we kept a carafe in the refrigerator designated for water. It’s a wine carafe but can put anything in it. My dad was an alcoholic so he had a wine carafe and a lot of other alcohol-related accoutrements like beer steins.

      • That’s a different issue from sandhi. Vocabulary and dialect are another area of active study (often paired with yet another realm: sociolinguistics: the language you speak changes according to your social environment) that is a real rabbit hole.

    • RandomException
      link
      fedilink
      English
      514 days ago

      I’ve been learning German too myself, and the thing that the traditional language courses don’t teach you is the way natives speak. Listening to actual German speakers was pretty much alien to me even after two years until I bumped into a couple Easy German videos where they touch the very same subject as this xkcd and that actually got me listening to certain parts of speech more carefully and that way also understand it better.

      Now I actually find myself doing the same shortcuts sometimes when I’m progressing with the skill. It’s the same with English since I have to use it daily at work even though I’m not a native speaker. Funny how the languages work in real life vs. in theory.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    7615 days ago

    My wife being bemused I don’t understand french in Paris after learning french for 3 years. Dude, they speak such sloppy french I’m impressed they understand each other.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      2115 days ago

      Agreed…I was especially impressed after I learned about their Verlan. As far as I can tell it’s basically pig Latin that they take seriously and use regularly as slang? As a quick example, the word Verlan is Verlan for l’envers. They can keep their secrets I guess haha.

      • @gentooer
        link
        English
        1715 days ago

        I think Verlan is pretty neat. We had a full lesson on it in middle school because of one of our country’s most popular musicians, Stromae, which is Verlan for Maestro.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          815 days ago

          Fantastic! Stromae is actually the reason I learned verlan existed! I got to see him live in the US, and it was one of the coolest live shows I’ve ever seen. The majority of the video for quand c’est is an actual part of the live show, and I wasn’t expecting it at all

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          7
          edit-2
          15 days ago

          Wait, Verlan is l’envers, stromae is maestro… Is this Verlan thing just like Rioplatense Spanish’s Vesre? (Vesre basically means revés i.e. inverse)

          EDIT: Just looked it up on Wikipedia and it turns out this phenomenon happens in a number of languages: Riocontra in Italian (riocontra -> contrario), Podaná in Greek, Šatrovački in Serbia, Totoiana in Romanian.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        1015 days ago

        Lol is that what happens when they have an official institute that dictates correct French? “Oh it’s not slang, it’s verlan!”

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      914 days ago

      Joseph Justus Scaliger said something similar about Basque in the 17th century:

      C’eſt un langage eſtrange que le Baſque… On dit, qu’ils s’entendent, je n’en crois rien

      Basque is a strange language… It is said that they understand one another, but I don’t believe any of it.

    • Zagorath
      link
      fedilink
      English
      21
      edit-2
      15 days ago

      I thought the same at first, but then I tried actually saying it out loud. “Yeah, I’m just gonna go to the shops”. And I actually think Munroe has it right here, at least for my accent. If I had been asked to say it and carefully analyse it myself, I probably wouldn’t have noticed at all that I was eliding more than “going to” to “gonna”. And if I had noticed, I still probably would have analysed it as (and I’m using Hangul here because frankly I don’t know how to spell out the vowel in the Latin alphabet in a way that actually makes sense) 근 (basically “gun”, but with a lazier vowel). But it’s definitely been elided down to a single syllable.

      The key thing is that this only happens when putting it into the middle of a full sentence. If it’s the only word I say, it stays “gonna”.

      edit: wait 🤦‍♂️. I can use IPA. I’d have analysed it as /gən/ But realistically, Munroe’s /gә̃/ is probably more accurate.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        715 days ago

        I can only get to /gә̃/ if I make an effort to say it faster than I ever actually talk. Otherwise, it definitely always has that “n” sound in there.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          2
          edit-2
          15 days ago

          Yeah, “gon’” seems about the most efficient form of “going to” that would be recognizable.

          Going to > gonna > gon’

          I guess if you’ve lived anywhere where speech has drifted a little hillbilly this version is just daily speech rather than any need for speed.

  • megane-kun
    link
    fedilink
    English
    3615 days ago

    I didn’t get it until I started trying to say “hot potato” in the middle of a sentence, like “Look out! Hot potato incoming!”

    The ‘t’ in “hot” became more and more like a glottal stop as my tongue started to touch the gums of my top front teeth less and less.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      915 days ago

      Still, I don’t think I could uncover that alien impersonator.

      “I’m goa have some hot potato.”

      Too me the “t” (at most) emphasises the hotness. Am I wrong?

      • megane-kun
        link
        fedilink
        English
        215 days ago

        The alien impersonator was me all along!‌ HAHAHA!!!

        I mean, seriously, I am not a native English speaker, but even with my weird English accent, it only became weirder if I try to speak fast while keeping the emphasis on that ‘t’ at the end of “hot”. My native accent also probably lends to that glottal stop taking over the ‘t’ and merging it with the upcoming ‘p’ sound. It also helps that the two sounds (glottal stop and the bilabial ‘p’) are on opposite sides of my mouth, so I‌ can quickly sound them in succession. The end result sounded to me like an exaggerated “posh British” rendition, as if the alien watched way too much‌ BBC before invading Earth.

        It just sounded way weirder than I otherwise would be. I can’t really describe it.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        015 days ago

        Are you the alien? Nobody calls a potato for eating hot potato… If you’re eating a potato it’s going to be hot. Hot potato is referring to the game where you pass something along very quickly. It’s saying you’re all passing something along that no one wants to get caught with or stuck with, and it’s almost never literally, it’s usually taking about a responsibility being passed or something like that.

  • @MajorHavoc
    link
    English
    2815 days ago

    Nice. There’s lots of areas I’ve lived where the locals drop specific consonants from the names of places. So anyone who actually pronounces the place name “correctly” is immediately recognized as new to town.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      1215 days ago

      I can only think if Toron(t)o. Never really thought about other towns doing the same thing.

      • Kernal64
        link
        fedilink
        English
        1215 days ago

        When I hear someone from that city say their city’s name, it sounds like it should be spelled “Trono.”

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          1115 days ago

          Shibboleths are amazing! Calgary is almost universally pronounced “Cal-Gary” by non-locals, locals say “Calgree”

          • Kernal64
            link
            fedilink
            English
            215 days ago

            I’m gonna have to disagree with you. Have you ever seen a Shoggoth? They’re horrific and just because they’re protoplasmic beings doesn’t mean their mispronunciation of English should be celebrated.

      • Zagorath
        link
        fedilink
        English
        715 days ago

        Like the other reply said, it’s all over the place in Australia. You can easily tell a tourist—especially an American tourist—because they’ll say “can-bair-a” instead of “can-bruh”.

        It’s not unusual in the UK, too. Worcester is Wost-er, Magdalen(e) is mawd-lin, and Leicester is lester.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          515 days ago

          OMG, that makes it so much worse. If someone tells you about a specific place, and you want to look it up later, you have absolutely zero chance of ever spelling it correctly. Good luck typing lester or woster in Wikipedia or Maps.

          • Zagorath
            link
            fedilink
            English
            615 days ago

            As it happens, that worked just fine:

            Worcester is famous even outside the UK because of Worcestershire sauce (pronounced “woster-shuh” sauce), the condiment named after the region. And because the name is on the bottle, it’s easy for people to remember.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        215 days ago

        We have a Bradenton nearby which gets shortened to branton (pronounced like brain-nton). Gotta have the long A or else you’ll accidently send someone half an hour away to Brandon.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          115 days ago

          Oh that’s just great. Two similar place names like that, and they also happen to be relatively close to each other. I can see how that could cause some confusion.

          Similarly, Kuhmo and Kuhmoinen (both in Finland) are about 446 km apart, but you can easily avoid the confusion as long as you know roughly which part of the country you’re talking about.

          There’s also Helsingborg (town in Sweden) and Helsinfors (swedish name for the capital of Finland). What could go wrong.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      215 days ago

      This is the real reason for English city names being Like That. It’s just the locals getting tired of using five syllables, and then four, and then three, over the course of literally a thousand years.

      We might find out the original name of London was Welsh before the Romans arrived to write it down.

  • cobysev
    link
    fedilink
    English
    2215 days ago

    See, my middle name ends with an S and my last name begins with an S… and my middle name is a pluralized name, so nobody hears the S when I say it in conjunction with my last name. So I’ve gotten really good at pronouncing the S, stopping for a beat, then saying my last name, without it sounding super weird or robotic.

    So properly pronouncing “hot potato” while enunciating the first T doesn’t seem too challenging to me.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    2015 days ago

    We English wouldn’t only drop the first t, we’d drop the h and the final t as well, 'o pota’o… innit

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      115 days ago

      And in my experience (or at least how I as a foreigner was taught the English RP pronounciation), often also the spaces between words.

      • RP drives me crazy with its bizarre pronunciation rules. Like never pronouncing ‘R’ unless it’s not there.

        “Law and order” under RP approximates “lo ran doh duh” where literally every ‘R’ in the phrase is not spoken, but they jam one in place of the ‘W’.

        ARGH! THE SPIDERS ARE EATING MY EYEBALLS FROM THE INSIDE!

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      615 days ago

      Phonetically, it’s exactly right, but It visually reads like the name of a Vulcan side character from an episode of star trek

  • Jakylla
    link
    fedilink
    English
    1515 days ago

    As a non native English speaker, I had to read your comments to understand the “Hot potato” one… Seems that I’m not as fluent in English as I thought (my accent is shit)

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    1215 days ago

    Hop-pa-taydo

    Also, the phrase “I’m going to” is often shortened to “I’mma” or “I’m ‘onna”. When referring to oneself, we tend to drop the G entirely

  • GTG3000
    link
    English
    814 days ago

    And in my case, it’d be more like /gna/. And yes I do pronounce the “t” in hot potato.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      414 days ago

      I feel like it’s the glottal T. I know for me, personally, my tongue doesn’t touch my teeth, but there is still a T sound. I am not British, though I am from Jersey (New).

      • GTG3000
        link
        English
        114 days ago

        My tongue definitely touches the teeth/roof of mouth there. I do swallow the vowels though.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        114 days ago

        I am from Jersey (New) too, and we love our our glottal stops. Once I was telling someone from out-of-state that I was from Trenton, and even after I said it three times, they still said they’d never heard of it. And I realized it’s because we pronounce it almost like “chre’in”. I don’t really pronounce the “nt” in the middle, it’s just a gap.

    • DeebsterOP
      link
      English
      314 days ago

      You pronounce the t in hot and then pronounce the p of potato?

      • GTG3000
        link
        English
        214 days ago

        Yeah. If I try going faster, it turns into “ht’ptayto”. Like a hard stop with tongue against the roof of the mouth before the teeth.

        Although admittedly, this is self-reporting.

        • DeebsterOP
          link
          English
          114 days ago

          I’m sitting here trying to replicate what that sounds like from your description and I’ve only succeeding in sounding like a madman.

          • GTG3000
            link
            English
            113 days ago

            Different accents, then.

    • If you’re a native-level speaker, no you don’t. You think you do. Assimilation is a real thing and is a huge part of all native language. NOBODY pronounces the way they think (and often loudly claim) that they do.

      Just like the people who claim they don’t have a “j” sound in “could you”.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        414 days ago

        How do you know that no-one enunicates the t sound? I just asked my partner to say hot potato and she definitely does.

        • You’re skewing the results by a bad test.

          Don’t “ask your partner” to say a particular word or phrase. The very act of asking that will have changed results. (This is experiment design 101 stuff here!) Ask her to read a lot of stuff that has “hot potato” in it in various places. (We tend to use sandhi in flowing streams of speech, not isolated clips.) Or, ideally, engage her in conversation and get her to say “hot potato” naturally as an organic outgrowth of the conversation.

          But … make sure you record what she says. Your own brain, as a listener, fills in stuff that’s not there while removing stuff that is. You have to play it back, concentrating on only the sounds, not the words, and do it repeatedly, ideally isolating this one phoneme at a time.

          Really, sandhi is a thing, and it’s a thing that literally every native speaker of every language in the world uses. There is variance by dialect, naturally (entire phones vanish or come out of nothing from dialect to dialect), but some elements of sandhi (like consonant assimilation) happen no matter what your dialect unless you’re specifically concentrating on having it not happen.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            114 days ago

            I don’t need to, i know she that correctly. There are definitely words we pronounce incorrectly but nit that one. You and the OP are conflating your local experience for a global one. I don’t live in the US, we enunciate differenrly

            • Look at the flags on my ID (not to mention the name in the middle).

              I do not live in the USA either.

              And trust me, unless you’re some kind of very weird outlier (and if you are, GO TO THE NEAREST UNIVERSITY’S LINGUISTICS DEPARTMENT IMMEDIATELY because you’re literally a dozen different Ph.D. theses in a single pair of people!) you use sandhi if you’re a native speaker. Period. You can no more avoid this than you can avoid being pulled toward the centre of the planet Earth.

              This is something that is well-researched. “I talked to my partner” doesn’t even qualify as anecdote!

      • GTG3000
        link
        English
        314 days ago

        Well, the only way to check beyond me muttering at myself would be to have a recording of me talking casually about hot potatoes :D

        And yeah, I definitely pronounce “could you” as “couja” when relaxed. Hanging out with people from different countries makes you pretty conscious about your accent some times. Mostly when half the voice chat can’t understand what you just said and the other half can’t understand why they’re having an issue.

        • Sandhi is a real thing. (Source: I had to study this shit to teach pronunciation classes.)

          It took me WEEKS to recognize that what I thought I was saying and what noises I was actually making are completely and utterly different. There’s often no relationship (like “coodja” for “could you” or “chrain” for “train”) between the intended sound and the actual sound … but since everybody does it you don’t notice until its forced into your face. The only time you make distinct sounds as per the “official” description (and even then not as often as you think: I submit “train” once again as evidence) is when you’re deliberately speaking slowly and distinctly. Which is almost never (and comes across as condescending in actual interaction).

          Weeks, I say again. WEEKS. And this was under constant training that included the playback of what we’d actually said showing us what we were doing. The denial is embedded deeply in our psyche.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            314 days ago

            I’d say part of this is the intended / official descriptipn isn’t actually that. The spoken word existed first, then someone tried to capture that spoken word using a finite list of characters and character combinations that map back to phenomes. The written word isn’t phonetically accurate to the letters it is composed of, and the written word is just close approximation of the spoken word itself.

            • That is absolutely correct. Writing isn’t language, in fact. Language is instinctual and barring severe brain damage, everybody on planet Earth learns to communicate in at least once. (Sign languages are language. Indeed they’re an extension of body language.)

              Writing is an attempted encoding of language (and not a very good one, given how much is lost in written form vs. in-person communication!) and is a skill that takes a lot of time and effort to learn. Writing is not instinctual in the slightest.

          • GTG3000
            link
            English
            213 days ago

            Yeah, as I said my awareness is just “people make fun of my accent some times” (and I make fun right back, it’s that kind of a friend group).

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        114 days ago

        My six year old daughter is getting the hanging of the spelling and whatnot, but earlier on in her Kindergarten year, words like “driver,” to her, started with a J. I had never thought about it, but it absolutely (at least in our NJ dialect) has a J sound, because, as you say, we all talk fucked up (paraphrasing).